How to compare loans from different banks: interest rate, fees or annual percentage rate of charge

02 october

You're looking at two adverts: "Cash loans from 0.01% per month" and "Loans at 29.9% per annum". The choice seems obvious. But then it turns out that the first loan will cost you UAH 10,000 more.


The interest rate on a loan does not always reflect its full cost: fees and other mandatory payments also affect it. In this article, I'll explain how to avoid being misled by an attractive figure and calculate the actual cost.

Why you shouldn't compare loans based on interest rates alone

The nominal interest rate shows only one component of the cost — the charge for borrowing the principal. However, a loan agreement almost never consists of just one figure. There may also be:

  • a loan disbursement or arrangement fee;
  • a monthly loan servicing fee;
  • mandatory life or property insurance;
  • application processing fees, money transfer fees and SMS notification charges;
  • one-off payments to third parties — valuers, notaries and registrars.

Legally, none of these are interest. In practice, however, they are all expenses paid out of your own pocket. That is why it is important to understand what the annual percentage rate of charge is: it is an indicator that allows you to assess the full cost of a loan, including payments specified in the agreement, rather than just the advertised interest rate.

To better understand how loan costs are calculated and how to work out the total additional borrowing cost, I previously wrote about this in the Unex Bank article "How to calculate interest on a loan?".

That is why a loan at 18% with a monthly fee of 1.2% costs more than a loan at 30% without fees. A monthly fee of 1.2% adds 14.4% of the original loan amount over 12 months if it is charged each month on an unchanged base.

The second trap is the calculation base. Some lenders calculate interest on the outstanding balance, which decreases every month. Others calculate it on the entire original amount throughout the loan term. If interest is charged on the original amount for the entire term, the additional borrowing cost can be significantly higher. At the same annual interest rate, the additional cost in the second case will be almost twice as high.

The third trap is "per month" instead of "per year". A monthly rate of 2% corresponds to a nominal annual rate of 24%; with monthly compounding, the effective annual rate is approximately 26.8%.

What figures should you consider when comparing loans?

To compare loans fairly, you need five figures, not just one:

  1. Nominal interest rate — the cost of borrowing money.
  2. All fees and mandatory payments — both one-off and recurring, including insurance if the loan cannot be obtained without it.
  3. Annual percentage rate of charge (APRC) — an indicator that combines the previous two points into a single figure. It is important to consider identical loan parameters, the composition of costs and the specific terms of the agreement.
  4. Total amount payable — how much money you will repay over the entire term.
  5. Monthly repayment — whether your budget can comfortably accommodate it.

There are also two parameters that are not cost figures themselves but affect the cost: the loan term and early repayment conditions. All else being equal, a longer term usually reduces the monthly repayment but increases the total amount of interest.

What is the annual percentage rate of charge and what does it include?

The annual percentage rate of charge is defined by the Law of Ukraine "On Consumer Lending". The APRC represents the overall cost of borrowing, including all the "extras": interest, lender fees, payments to credit intermediaries and the cost of mandatory related services provided by third parties, such as insurance, valuations and notarial services. Everything you must pay to obtain the loan is included in the calculation.

What is not included in the APRC? Fines and penalties for late payments (these result from your actions rather than being a condition of obtaining the loan), as well as optional services that you can decline without affecting the loan.


The annual percentage rate of charge is not estimated approximately — it is calculated according to the methodology established by the NBU. If you are looking for the formula for calculating the annual percentage rate of charge, it is based on comparing all the money the borrower receives from the bank with all the payments they must make in return. The dates of these transactions are also taken into account. Put simply, the calculation shows the actual annual cost of the loan, including not only interest but also other mandatory payments.

For your own calculations in Excel, you can use the XIRR function. Enter the loan amount received as a negative figure in the spreadsheet, followed by all future payments and their corresponding dates. The function determines the annual rate at which these cash flows balance — providing a reference point for the APRC.

The main thing to remember is that the annual percentage rate of charge is an important standardised indicator that helps compare the cost of consumer loans. However, to fully assess an offer, you should also consider the total amount payable, the repayment schedule and the terms of the agreement.

How does the annual percentage rate of charge differ from the loan interest rate?

There are three differences:

  • What is included. The nominal rate covers interest only. The APRC includes interest plus all mandatory payments.
  • Calculation method. The nominal rate is a simple linear figure. The APRC takes into account the effect of compound interest and the repayment schedule: exactly when you pay and how much. A payment made in the first month carries more weight than the same payment made at the end of the term.
  • Purpose. The nominal rate is used to calculate interest in the repayment schedule. The APRC is used to compare different loan offers.

To illustrate: a loan without any fees, with interest charged on the outstanding balance, will have an APRC slightly higher than its nominal rate because of monthly compounding. A loan with a monthly fee may have an APRC two or three times its nominal rate. The greater the difference between these two figures, the more of the loan's cost is hidden outside the advertised interest rate.

How does the interest calculation method affect the total borrowing cost?

There is another detail that is easy to overlook when comparing loans — the method used to count the days for which interest is charged. You may encounter the terms Actual/Actual, Actual/360 or 30/360 in a loan agreement. They determine how the number of days is converted into a fraction of a year for calculating interest.

  • Actual/Actual — uses the actual number of calendar days in the period and the actual number of days in the relevant year: 365 or 366.
  • Actual/360 — uses the actual number of calendar days during which the loan is outstanding but divides them by an assumed 360-day year.
  • 30/360 — assumes that each month has 30 days and the year has 360 days. The specific rules may depend on the version of this convention.

Why does this matter? If the outstanding balance and nominal annual interest rate are the same, the Actual/360 method will generally produce more interest over the same actual period than Actual/Actual in an ordinary year, because the denominator of 360 is smaller than 365. The difference may be even more noticeable in a leap year.

For example, if interest is charged at 30% per annum on an unchanged outstanding balance of UAH 100,000 for 30 actual days:

  • using Actual/Actual in a 365-day year: 100,000 × 30% × 30 / 365 ≈ UAH 2,465.75;
  • using Actual/360: 100,000 × 30% × 30 / 360 = UAH 2,500.

The difference for this period is approximately UAH 34.25.

The 30/360 method does not always produce a result between these two figures: everything depends on the calendar dates and the rules of the particular convention. Therefore, you should not draw conclusions based solely on the name of the method — check how it is defined in the agreement and how it affects the repayment schedule.

Please note that the amounts above merely illustrate the effect of the day-count convention on interest for one period. They are not an APRC calculation or a comparison of specific banking products.

How do fees affect the actual cost of a loan?

A one-off loan arrangement fee has the greatest impact on shorter terms. If 2% is deducted from the loan amount, it will add approximately 2 percentage points to the APRC over 24 months, but as much as 8 percentage points over six months.

A monthly fee is the most expensive component. It is almost always calculated on the original loan amount and does not decrease as the principal is repaid. A monthly fee of 0.9% on a UAH 100,000 loan means UAH 900 every month, regardless of whether you still owe UAH 90,000 or just UAH 5,000.

Insurance costs range from 0.3% to 1% per month, depending on the programme. If the loan cannot be obtained without insurance, it is a mandatory payment and must be included in the APRC.

There are also "hidden" expenses that may not appear in the calculation: account maintenance fees, charges for repaying a loan through a branch cashier or another bank's payment terminal, and transfer fees. They may not be included in the total cost of the loan, but you still pay them out of your own pocket. That is why you should always ask how to make repayments free of charge.

How to compare loans from different banks correctly

Here is the process I recommend following, literally with a pencil in hand.

Step 1. Set the parameters

Use the same amount, the same term and the same repayment type (annuity or equal principal repayments). There is no point comparing UAH 50,000 over one year with UAH 70,000 over two years.

Step 2. Create a shortlist

There is no universal answer to the question of which bank is best for a cash loan: each lender has its own profile of preferred customers. Look at which banks serve your particular category.

If applying without visiting a branch is important to you, check which banks offer online loans and whether the entire process is genuinely remote, rather than "apply online, sign the agreement at a branch".

If you are serving in the military, check separately which banks offer loans to military personnel: some lenders have special terms for this category and a different approach to income verification.

More generally, the question of which banks provide loans during wartime has a straightforward answer today — banks may continue lending, but loan availability and requirements depend on the particular lender.

Step 3. Obtain the consumer credit information sheet

The consumer credit information sheet is a standardised document that the lender provides to the consumer free of charge before the agreement is signed. It sets out the main lending terms, including the amount, term, interest rate, borrowing costs and estimated annual percentage rate of charge.

Check the validity period of the information stated in the document and use it to compare offers from different lenders. However, the law requires the validity period of the information to be specified and prohibits restricting the time consumers have to review it.

Step 4. Compare the APRC and total amount payable

These are two key figures that help assess the actual cost of borrowing. The APRC shows the annual cost of the loan, including expenses specified in the agreement, while the total amount payable shows how much money you will actually repay the bank over the entire term. Together, they help you understand not only the interest rate but also the final cost of the loan.

Step 5. Check the repayment schedule

Don't focus solely on the monthly repayment amount — review the entire schedule from beginning to end. Pay particular attention to the first and last months: check whether payments increase, whether there is a separate fee at the end of the term and whether the amount changes because of special contractual conditions.

Step 6. Read the early repayment clause

Check the early repayment conditions: whether you can repay the loan in full or in part before the agreed date, how payments are recalculated in that case and whether you need to notify the lender in advance. The terms must comply with consumer lending legislation.

Example of comparing two loan offers

The conditions are identical: UAH 100,000 over 24 months, with annuity repayments.

Bank A Bank B
  • Nominal interest rate

    22% per annum

  • Loan arrangement fee

    2% (UAH 2,000)

  • Monthly fee

    0.9% of the loan amount (UAH 900)

  • Monthly repayment

    UAH 6,088

  • Additional borrowing cost

    UAH 48,112

  • Total amount payable

    UAH 148,112

  • APRC

    ≈ 50.8%

  • Nominal interest rate

    32% per annum

  • Loan arrangement fee

    None

  • Monthly fee

    None

  • Monthly repayment

    UAH 5,695

  • Additional borrowing cost

    UAH 36,680

  • Total amount payable

    UAH 136,680

  • APRC

    ≈ 37.1%

Indicator

Bank A

Bank B

Nominal interest rate

22% per annum

32% per annum

Loan arrangement fee

2% (UAH 2,000)

None

Monthly fee

0.9% of the loan amount (UAH 900)

None

Monthly repayment

UAH 6,088

UAH 5,695

Additional borrowing cost

UAH 48,112

UAH 36,680

Total amount payable

UAH 148,112

UAH 136,680

APRC

≈ 50.8%

≈ 37.1%

The difference in the nominal interest rate is 10 percentage points in favour of Bank A. The difference in actual money is UAH 11,432 in favour of Bank B.

Why did this happen? Over two years, Bank A's fees added UAH 2,000 as a one-off charge and UAH 21,600 in monthly payments — a total of UAH 23,600 that has nothing to do with the "22% per annum" advertised on the banner. Bank B charges higher interest, but calculates it on the outstanding balance, which decreases every month.

This is exactly what I mean when I say that cash loans can only be compared based on the total amount repayable, not the advertised interest rate.

Here's another example showing that a lower interest rate means a cheaper loan

Let's compare two lending models for the same amount — UAH 100,000 over 25 months. The first uses the actual terms of Unex Bank's White Loan. The second is a hypothetical offer designed to illustrate how monthly fees can increase the cost of borrowing.

Unex Bank White Loan Hypothetical offer
  • Loan amount

    UAH 100,000

  • Term

    25 months

  • Nominal interest rate

    28.9% per annum

  • One-off fee

    3.9%

  • Monthly fee

    0%

  • Total amount payable

    UAH 143,195.24

  • APRC

    38.41%

  • Loan amount

    UAH 100,000

  • Term

    25 months

  • Nominal interest rate

    0.01% per annum

  • One-off fee

    5%

  • Monthly fee

    1.8% of the original amount

  • Total amount payable

    More than UAH 150,000 under the stated assumptions

  • APRC

    Requires a separate calculation based on the full repayment schedule

Indicator

Unex Bank White Loan

Hypothetical offer

Loan amount

UAH 100,000

UAH 100,000

Term

25 months

25 months

Nominal interest rate

28.9% per annum

0.01% per annum

One-off fee

3.9%

5%

Monthly fee

0%

1.8% of the original amount

Total amount payable

UAH 143,195.24

More than UAH 150,000 under the stated assumptions

APRC

38.41%

Requires a separate calculation based on the full repayment schedule

For a Unex Bank loan of UAH 100,000 over 25 months, with a base interest rate of 28.9% per annum and a one-off fee of 3.9%, the estimated total cost is UAH 143,195.24, and the APRC is 38.41%.

Now let's look at the hypothetical offer. A fee of 1.8% of the original loan amount is UAH 1,800 per month. Over 25 months, this amounts to UAH 45,000. There is also a UAH 5,000 one-off fee. So fees alone total UAH 50,000, excluding interest and any other possible charges.

Therefore, an interest rate of 0.01% per annum does not, in itself, make the hypothetical loan cheaper. Under these assumptions, the fees already outweigh the difference that a low nominal interest rate might create.

This is a simplified comparison, and the final total amount payable and APRC must be determined using the full repayment schedule, exact payment dates, fee calculation base and all mandatory expenses.

This is exactly what I mean when I say that cash loans can only be compared based on the total amount repayable, not the advertised interest rate.

Which indicator best reflects the actual cost of a loan?

If you need a single figure, it is the APRC. It is calculated using the same methodology for all lenders and takes into account interest, fees and the repayment schedule. Two loans with the same amount and term should be compared using this indicator.

If you want the complete picture, look at the combination of "APRC + total amount payable". The first figure shows the cost of borrowing as a percentage, while the second shows it in the hryvnias you will actually repay.

One important caution: the APRC provides a fair comparison only for loans with the same term. A three-month loan will almost always have a higher APRC than a three-year loan, even if it costs less in hryvnias: one-off fees are spread over a shorter period, mathematically inflating the rate. So if the terms differ, compare the total additional borrowing cost.

What else should you consider before taking out a loan?

Before applying, you should check more than just the interest rate and total additional borrowing cost. Loan terms may include additional expenses, restrictions and obligations that affect the actual cost. Pay attention to the following:

  • Repayment type. Annuity repayments are equal, making budgeting easier, but the total borrowing cost is higher. Under the equal principal repayment method, payments decrease over time and the total cost is lower, but the initial payments are higher.
  • Early repayment. Can you make partial repayments? Will this shorten the term or reduce the monthly payment? Is advance notice required?
  • Right of withdrawal. Within 14 calendar days of signing, you can withdraw from the agreement by repaying the principal and interest for the actual days of borrowing. No fee may be charged for exercising this right.
  • Fines and penalties. The total amount of contractual penalties is limited by law, but the amounts specified in agreements vary — check them.
  • Links to other products. "A lower rate if you take out a card and insurance" — calculate the cost of the entire package.
  • Repayment channels. A UAH 20 fee for each payment adds another UAH 480 over two years.
  • Reporting to credit bureaus. Every loan contributes to your credit history, and overdue payments on even a "small" loan can close the door to a mortgage or car loan.
How to choose the better-value loan

I'll summarise everything in a short checklist — this is the answer to how to compare loans without having to do all the calculations in your head. So:

  1. Decide on the amount and term, and keep them unchanged throughout the comparison.
  2. Obtain a consumer credit information sheet from each lender.
  3. Write down the figures in one line: interest rate → fees → APRC → total amount payable.
  4. Choose the lowest total amount payable, not the lowest interest rate.
  5. Check whether your budget can accommodate the monthly repayment with at least a 20% safety margin.
  6. Read the early repayment conditions — this is your opportunity to save money.
  7. Sign only what you have read in full, including any tariffs linked to in the agreement.

There is no single correct answer for everyone to the question of which bank is best for a loan. But there is a correct method: always compare the annual percentage rate of charge and the total amount payable. Comparing the terms will help you avoid unnecessary expenses and better assess the full cost of borrowing.


Translation into English was created with the help of artificial intelligence.

icon star icon star icon star

Хочеш залишити відгук про роботу Unex Bank?